Size up at least a half size—these shoes run small and narrow, especially in the toe box and width. Praised for comfort, versatility, and a classic look that pairs well with casual outfits and indoor sports. The premium leather construction and cushioning earn consistent approval for everyday wear.
AI-generated summary
14 Customer Photos
1-10 of 102 Reviews
Most Recent
Most Helpful
Oldest
Highest Rated
Lowest Rated
(57)
(20)
(12)
(5)
(8)
Frequently Mentioned
Key themes mentioned in review generated by AI analysis.
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Great looking shoes
I love these shoes, they look amazing, they are light and easy to wear for long periods of time. My only complaint is that they are narrow at the front, I did order half a size bigger, but they still feel too tight.
CarlosE798468123
Aug 16, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
10
Was this helpful?
Review by CarlosE798468123 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 2 out of 5
Beware of size
I consistently wear size 13 shoes but these are about an entire size smaller than should be. Even compared to other Nike shoes, theyre VERY small. The brown version looks fantastic and was very excited right up until i tried them on. BEWARE OF SIZE!
Ryandh32
Jul 30, 2026
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by Ryandh32 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Best ever combinations go get you some comforings
The color are very nice together the shoes are nice
Berry
Jul 20, 2026
Location
Arkansas
Originally posted at Hibbett Sports
Was this helpful?
Review by Berry has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Average
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Calm shoes
Very nice and chill. I’d say definitely half size up. i have kinda a wider foot than average and 10.5 rather than a 10 fits well. chill calm low top shoe
danielg448396986
Jun 26, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
10
Was this helpful?
Review by danielg448396986 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Average
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
The Nike Gato is a beautiful shoe, very nice materials. Runs small, so get 1 or 1.5 size bigger. My complaints is that it’s a little narrow at the toes. & for this colorway the Dark Pony, they put vinyl on the inside of the sock liner & even the tongue instead of the regular material or leather, it’s horrible. It’s hot, it makes annoying noises, it’s somewhat abrasive on your socks so I can only…
StevenJ719502165
Jun 15, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
11
Was this helpful?
Review by StevenJ719502165 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 3 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Average
Would you recommend this product?:No
run VERY small
They look good, though didn't look quite as good out of the box as in pictures. The bigger issue is the sizing - I sized up a half size like the listing says and they were still way too tight. I'd recommend going up a full size from normal.
Justin721033197
Jun 3, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
10
Was this helpful?
Review by Justin721033197 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Big
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Very nice my wife like the shoes
franciscop413538034
Jun 3, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
8.5
Was this helpful?
Review by franciscop413538034 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 1 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Uncomfortable
Would you recommend this product?:No
Very very narrow
These shoes are very, very narrow. Did not fit and have to return. Also, they do not look like the casual, everyday shoe that is depicted on the website. They are instead more like a goofy kickball shoe. Hard to describe but not a fan.
MatthewM330698760
Jun 2, 2026
Location
South Daytona, FL, US
Size you normally wear
10.5
Was this helpful?
Review by MatthewM330698760 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Great Retro Sneakers
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My husband loves these sneakers! Fits great, nice colors. Classic look!
Product received for free, or reviewed as part of a prize draw/giveaway or in exchange for a discount.
NoreenCK
Jun 2, 2026
Location
Berkeley Heights, NJ
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by NoreenCK has been flagged
Flag
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Uncomfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
I don’t understand why these are sized the way they are
Nice shoes but I’ve been wearing size 11-1/2 in Nike for 30+ years and they’ve always fit the same. I don’t know why these are sized the way they are but definitely order up. The website says consider ordering a half size larger than usual but even the 12 are feeling too snug. Annoying to deal with if you’re ordering online.
