Praised for exceptional comfort and cushioning that feels ready for running right out of the box. The shoes perform well for running, gym workouts, and everyday wear, with the midsole holding up through extended use. Fit runs narrow even in the wide version—sizing up or choosing wide is recommended, especially for those needing true 4E width. The elastic laces require some adjustment to secure properly without discomfort.
AI-generated summary
3 Customer Photos
10 Reviews
Most Recent
Most Helpful
Oldest
Highest Rated
Lowest Rated
(6)
(3)
(0)
(0)
(1)
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
🏃🖤
I bought these for my boyfriend who usually uses them for every day purposes. He’s a size 10.5 normally, but the heel sneakers are a little more narrow - so he gets 10.5 wide. They are so comfy ! You can tell how cushioned they are by holding them. They feel like they’re made for running. As soon as you put them on you want to start running 😃 def recommend
Kaitlyn586575116
Jul 21, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
10.5
What activity do you use this product for?
Everyday wear
Was this helpful?
Review by Kaitlyn586575116 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Average
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Nice effort, great shoe, needs more work
Fit is nice although varries often due to elasticity of laces. To secure them well without causing discomfort takes practice. Heal doesn't lock in. Far too few color/style options for wide. Mid-sole is great until 300 miles, then fades quickly.
DeanM590386542
Jun 30, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
10
What activity do you use this product for?
Mid-range runs (4-12 miles)
What surface do you usually run on?
Road
Was this helpful?
Review by DeanM590386542 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Look and feel great. Best shoes I’ve tried.
I tried a lot of different running shoes and these were the most comfortable. They feel and look great. I hope Nike continues to offer their premium shoes in wide.
RHubz
Jun 9, 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
9.5
What activity do you use this product for?
Shorter runs (1-3 miles)
What surface do you usually run on?
Road
Was this helpful?
Review by RHubz has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Solid overall
There are better specifically running shoes but if you want one shoe that can also be used in the gym or park or most other activities including running at different speeds then this is a very solid option.
Dennis
Jun 5, 2026
Location
Laguna Niguel CA
Originally posted at Road Runner
Was this helpful?
Review by Dennis has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Best Pegasus!
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've bought Pegasus forever and these are the most comfortable version! I love them and I may have to buy another color!
Product received for free, or reviewed as part of a prize draw/giveaway or in exchange for a discount.
Kkyy10
May 20, 2026
Location
Dublin, OH
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by Kkyy10 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
GREAT SHOE!!
Great shoe for long runs! Stays comfortable! And wears like iron!
dorunrun
May 19, 2026
Location
NW Ohio
Originally posted at Road Runner
Was this helpful?
Review by dorunrun has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Perfect!!
Fit great, feel great, perform great!!
Steve
May 11, 2026
Location
Austin
Originally posted at Road Runner
Was this helpful?
Review by Steve has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
I've been buying Pegasus since they first came out lo thos…4
Comfortable, great for workout running every day wear
Mikey
May 4, 2026
Location
NM
Originally posted at Road Runner
Was this helpful?
Review by Mikey has been flagged
Flag
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Great for supination
The Pegasus 42 is a very comfortable shoe, especially good for supination which I have, but it is not much wider than the normal version. I’d honestly say it’s literally like going up half a size in the normal version. Shame as it’s a great shoe
David216166708
Apr 25, 2026
Location
GB
Size you normally wear
9.5
What activity do you use this product for?
Everyday wear
Was this helpful?
Review by David216166708 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 1 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Uncomfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Disappointed, too narrow.
Pegasus 40 was my favorite running shoe, ever. Bought 2 pairs, should have bought more. Pegasus 41 was too narrow. I had hope for 42 because Nike stated they made the toe box roomier. But this shoe is even tighter than the 41. The toebox of the Pegasus 42 is almost 10mm narrower than the Pegasus 40 and the gusseted tongue makes the shoe too tight on my arches. Too tight all around. If you wear D…
