AI analysis found these key themes mentioned in reviews.
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Love - Great for hikes!
They are extremely comfortable, look fantastic, match with everything and are absolutely perfect for my hikes with my dog. I ordered a second pair last week.
carolynv763686988
13 Jun 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
6
What activity is this product used for?
Walking
What type of surface do you usually run on?
Trail
Was this helpful?
Review by carolynv763686988 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Waterproof & durable!
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I got these slo I could stay dry in the rain. Definitely exceeded expectations. These shoes have been trough it in the few weeks I’ve had them & still look new. Comfy & love the bright colors!
Product received for free, or reviewed as part of a prize draw/giveaway or in exchange for a discount.
mauler
2 Jun 2026
Location
MO
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by mauler has been flagged
Flag
Rated 2 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Not Waterproof
Both times I’ve worn them in wet weather, my feet got wet. Aside from that, they’re some of my most comfortable shoes.
katemiller7
17 May 2026
Location
US
Was this helpful?
Review by katemiller7 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Great trail shoe
Ive had these for a few months now and ive had no issues eith durability or comfortability. I wear them whenever its been raining and have no real issues with wet feet or slipping. Overall, great shoe!
Christinameana
1 May 2026
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by Christinameana has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Best in my shoe collection
I have these in 2 colors. Best support of all my athletic shoe collection. The cushion lining around the ankle makes for a great fit. No need for time to break in the shoes. Great for everything right out of the box.
Staceykim
21 Apr 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
4.5
What activity is this product used for?
Cross-training
What type of surface do you usually run on?
Road
Was this helpful?
Review by Staceykim has been flagged
Flag
Rated 2 out of 5
How did this product fit?:Runs Small
How comfortable was this product?:Uncomfortable
Would you recommend this product?:No
Very disappointed! Order at least 1/2 size bigger! Runs extremely small tight and very narrow The area where the shoe tongue is gave me a lot of pain
Loretta375318188
30 Mar 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
4
What activity is this product used for?
Mid-range runs (4–12 miles)
What type of surface do you usually run on?
Treadmill / indoors
Was this helpful?
Review by Loretta375318188 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Very Comfortable
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Comfy Right Out of the Box; Supportive & Dry All Day Long on Winter Trails
There was no breaking-in period for these -- comfortable right out of the box. I hike 3-6 miles almost every day on trails, and bought these to keep my feet warm and dry during snowy and wet winter hikes as low as 0°. These do not disappoint! My feet stayed supported and dry even in 4 -5 inches or more of snow and on very uneven terrain. I loved them so much I bought a second pair locally, since…
SusanD946248510
10 Feb 2026
Location
US
Size you normally wear
5.5
What activity is this product used for?
Walking
What type of surface do you usually run on?
Trail
Was this helpful?
Review by SusanD946248510 has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Nice
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Bought these for my daughter. She said they're very comfortable
Product received for free, or reviewed as part of a prize draw/giveaway or in exchange for a discount.
Yo mo
28 Jan 2026
Location
Gainesville Florida
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by Yo mo has been flagged
Flag
Rated 5 out of 5
Great product
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good price. Looking forward to trying them out soon
Product received for free, or reviewed as part of a prize draw/giveaway or in exchange for a discount.
Cats
21 Jan 2026
Location
Santa Maria
Originally posted at DICK'S Sporting Goods
Was this helpful?
Review by Cats has been flagged
Flag
Rated 4 out of 5
How did this product fit?:True to Size
How comfortable was this product?:Average
Would you recommend this product?:Yes
Good enough but not as good as Pegasus Trail 4 Gore-Tex
The shoes use the "rocker" design at the bottom, which makes it stiller than its predecessor, my beloved Trail 4. In winter conditions, the bottom seems to perform well, but I can't do a side by side comparison with my Trail 4, which I had left (forgotten) at a trail head hundreds of miles away. The Trail 5 is also not as deep, making it harder to wade through steams.
